The Daily Ping

Apple did not consult with us when they named Ping, Ping.

March 13th, 2003

Comedies in the Past

Wow. Sorry for being late today.

I’ve noticed that I enjoy “nostalgia” shows… shows that take place in the past and whose identity is defined by the decade. The Wonder Years, Freaks and Geeks, and even That 70’s Show have all done admirable jobs at setting their characters firmly in the past in a believable fashion. Anachronisms are rare, which really helps the quality of a show of this type.

However, when a show’s only gimmick is that it’s set in the past, it fails miserably. That 70’s Show succeeds because while it takes place in the 70s and is believable as such, they don’t pound you over the head ever five minutes by throwing out a 70s pop culture reference. Rather, they build strong storylines that happen to take place 25 years in the past. Where That 80’s Show failed, and failed miserably, was that everything was so forced, so… 80s… that watching it was a chore beyond chores.

FOX’s “new breed of comedy,” Oliver Beene has quickly fallen into the That 80s Show trap. In this new show, which debuted last Sunday after The Simpsons, a slightly dysfunctional 60s family goes through the motions and acts in ways that are supposed to make us laugh. Unfortunately, the marketing hype surrounding the show and the heavy handed writing made the premiere episode nothing short of a disaster. Aside from the Oliver Beene himself, every character is poorly cast and poorly played. The script dripped with forced humor and the cinematography tried too hard to be fast and “clippy,” which was just jarring. It’s honestly one of the worst sitcoms I’ve seen in quite a long time. It’s that bad.

What are your favorite comedies set in the past (or future, for that matter)?

Posted in Television, Movies, and Music

FROM: Greg C
DATE: Thursday March 13, 2003 -- 12:30:17 pm
The Adventures of Brisco County, Jr... technically it wasn't a comedy but did have quite a few humorous moments. Plus it had Bruce Campbell!



FROM: jk
DATE: Thursday March 13, 2003 -- 12:45:04 pm
Freaks and Geeks was great, and as my one friend theorizes, it was sooo realistic that it failed. (They were just "normal-looking" kids going through the good and bad things that happened to us when we were that age.)

I agree that That 80s Show was unwatchable.



FROM: jk
DATE: Thursday March 13, 2003 -- 12:46:32 pm
PS-when I awoke this morning and saw that it was still 3/12, I thought I was having a Groundhog Day moment. Yesterday was my birthday and I feared having to re-live it again and again! Thank you for clearing everything up. Am I still 29? (again)



FROM: Chris [E-Mail]
DATE: Thursday March 13, 2003 -- 12:52:19 pm
I think the key to success in these shows is that the good ones make you realize that the important stuff never really changes. The styles and culture are just window dressing. That said, Wonder Years is probably my favorite.



FROM: Matt
DATE: Friday March 14, 2003 -- 4:55:44 pm
Quantum Leap!!! It wasn't a comedy, but you couldn't help but laugh at Scott Bakula.



FROM: Robert [E-Mail]
DATE: Friday March 14, 2003 -- 5:54:57 pm
Futurama!



FROM: towinlovinit
DATE: Friday March 21, 2003 -- 12:01:12 am
My favorite then and reruns now is still and will ever be: The Cosby Show. I love it!



What is this then?

The Daily Ping is the web's finest compendium of toilet information and Oreo™® research. Too much? Okay, okay, it's a daily opinion column written by two friends. Did we mention we've been doing this for over ten years? Tell me more!

Most Popular Pings

Last Week's Most Popular Pings

Let's be nice.

© 2000-2011 The Daily Ping, all rights reserved. Tilted sidebar note idea 'adapted' from Panic. Powered by the mighty WordPress.