The Daily Ping

Somehow, Ryan has written over 1 million Pings; Paul, just 60.

November 20th, 2000

Jakob Nielsen Probably Doesn’t Like Driving Much

I promise I’m not going to go Jakob Nielsen on you. While some of his arguments are sound, many are just plain wacky and/or absurd.

One of the points he brings up, however, is an interesting parallel to something else we deal with daily (unless you don’t have one, and the earth loves you for it), our cars. Jakob’s big mantra is that web stores must have a consistent look and feel or will die. He also says that Flash movies suck in part due to the lack of a standard interface. When you work with a computer, there are standards: scrollbars, mouse movement, and so on. When it’s the web, there are no standards. I’m going to go ahead and agree with Jakob on this one. Make scrollbars look fancy, make them huge, make them animated, but make them work as we know them.

When you sit in a new car, there is always, always an adjustment period. The lights work differently, the radio works differently, and the biggest stickler is cruise control. There just aren’t any standards for this. The HVAC controls are another fun one. It’s interesting to note that these controls are probably the most important to a car’s function and your safety, yet there’s no standard. If GM wants, they can put a headlight control up on the ceiling if they really want to (it’ll appeal to about 1% of the car buying public, but still.)

Just as in web design, some elements of the car’s interface will go throw a Darwin shakeout… but with cars, it tends to take a longer period of time. Okay, much longer. But wouldn’t it be nice if you could sit in a car and know where the controls are going to be?

Then again, Jakob would say, "Wouldn’t it be nice if you could visit a site and know where the controls are going to be?" -pm

Posted in Cars

FROM: Terry Murphy
DATE: Monday November 20, 2000 -- 1:04:22AM
A couple of weeks ago on a trip when I rented a car for some inane reason they gave me a ptcruiser. The window controls for that ridiculous car are on the dashboard. So, when I went to the little drive-through to check out, the guy was laughing at me because I had to open the door because I couldn't figure out how to open the window. Talk about a bad, inconsistent user interface on a car. It's not as bad as Word though.



FROM: Paul
DATE: Monday November 20, 2000 -- 8:25:40AM
Terry, I'm going to demonstrate my newfound craziness and agree with you. I like the PT Cruiser - a lot. (If it were actually available, I probably would have gotten one this past July.) However, the power window switch placement is beyond curious.

It should be noted that the rear power window switches are on the back of the center console! Huh? I believe it's a limitation in the Neon platform on which the PT is based - the Neon just doesn't have power rear windows (even with power fronts).



FROM: Robert
DATE: Monday November 20, 2000 -- 8:46:56AM
Who exactly is this Jakob Nielsen and where is he employed? Is it at the Wacky Factory?



FROM: Ryan
DATE: Monday November 20, 2000 -- 9:08:15AM
Robert -- useit.com.



FROM: Robert
DATE: Monday November 20, 2000 -- 12:22:17PM
Oh, a professional expert. And quite a looker, I might add. I can see how he became one of the top 10 most influential internet thingy dudes.



What is this then?

The Daily Ping is the web's finest compendium of toilet information and Oreo™® research. Too much? Okay, okay, it's a daily opinion column written by two friends. Did we mention we've been doing this for over ten years? Tell me more!

Most Popular Pings

Last Week's Most Popular Pings

Let's be nice.

© 2000-2011 The Daily Ping, all rights reserved. Tilted sidebar note idea 'adapted' from Panic. Powered by the mighty WordPress.