The Daily Ping

Can't get enough of Paul and Ryan collaborations? Visit the It's 2011, Folks tumblelog!

October 5th, 2005

It’s Illegal to Listen to CDs

The other day I got a CD in the mail. When I put it into my computer, autorun kicked in and I was asked to agree to some sort of EULA. As usual, I paid no attention and figured it had something to do with CD-ROM content. Turns out, I was actually agreeing to not be able to listen to my CD the way I wanted to.

See, the CD had MediaMax copy protection on it. And once I agreed to the end user license, I was able to only listen to the CD through their own proprietary player or rip it to “secure” WMA (no MP3s!). When I tried to listen to it with QCD, it was choppy and garbled.

This pissed me off. Greatly. The company that makes MediaMax tries to make their system look like it’s the bee’s knees because it doesn’t hamper you from playing the CD the way you want to and, *gasp*, even lets you make digital copies! They’re so nice!

But they’re not, really.

After reading through the Princeton link above, I saw that if I had autorun turned off or held down SHIFT to prevent autorun from starting on that disc, I would have been fine (real secure, Sunncomm). But now the stupid software and licenses were on my machine and there’s no way to remove them. Fortunately, there is a way to disable them (also mentioned in the Princeton link in section 3). So, I disabled it and ripped the songs to MP3 format.

Now, I’m not going to go share these MP3 files with the world. They’re not even shared on the network. All I wanted to do was have my own copy of these songs, in my selected format, to listen to them. And I had to jump through hoops not just to rip the CD, but to listen to it. Absurd and asinine. If the record industry keeps up with crap like this, they will totally and completely alienate their customers.

Plus, after all that, the CD sucked.

Posted in Miscellaneous

FROM: Paul
DATE: Wednesday October 5, 2005 -- 11:00:19 am
Wow, geez. What?

That's insane. You're trying to listen to music, not play Global Thermonuclear War. (Heck, that was easier to do!)

It's also a bummer that the CD was no good - I've found that most Sarah McLachlan remixes are really, really hit-or-miss, though.

DATE: Wednesday October 5, 2005 -- 1:20:30 pm
The first thing I do upon buying music from Itunes is run Jhymn on it to disable the drm. I bought the damn music, if I want to load it on a computer in every room in my house I should be able to do it. I'm paranoid, I like backups.

On that note - Harvey Danger is providing a drm free download of their entire new album.

FROM: Authorized Duplication Is Outlawed
DATE: Wednesday October 5, 2005 -- 1:48:28 pm
If they're going to use copy protection like that (which they shouldn't), they should state that they are trying to prevent AUTHORIZED duplication (which is more illegal than unauthorized duplication).

FROM: jk
DATE: Wednesday October 5, 2005 -- 9:49:25 pm
Paul, would you like to play a game?

I love you guys.

FROM: Merle [E-Mail]
DATE: Sunday October 9, 2005 -- 9:33:54 pm
Always disable autorun. It's about the third thing I do when I get a new Win-computer (first, fix explorer settings; second, download TweakUI).

What amazes me is that people think this protection might actually work. If you could find a workaround and this much info on it so quickly...

On the other hand, in the space of ten minutes I made both my DVD players "region free". Maybe there's just a lot more information out there nowadays...

FROM: Marcus
DATE: Wednesday October 26, 2005 -- 1:03:30 am
I always name my personal Mac, "Joshua"? ;-) It's become a tradition. :-)

My PC's named HAL. :-D


FROM: Aanen
DATE: Wednesday November 9, 2005 -- 5:05:52 pm
Here's an interesting article that my security prof pointed out

What is this then?

The Daily Ping is the web's finest compendium of toilet information and Oreo™® research. Too much? Okay, okay, it's a daily opinion column written by two friends. Did we mention we've been doing this for over ten years? Tell me more!

Most Popular Pings

Last Week's Most Popular Pings

Let's be nice.

© 2000-2011 The Daily Ping, all rights reserved. Tilted sidebar note idea 'adapted' from Panic. Powered by the mighty WordPress.